There are several grounds for objecting to subpoena family court.
You can challenge a subpoena if it is oppressive, too broad, irrelevant to the case, or if it breaches legal privilege or confidentiality.
The court has the power to set aside or limit the subpoena if it finds that complying would be unfair or unnecessary.
What is a Subpoena in Family Court?
A subpoena is a legal document issued by the court that compels a person to provide documents, give evidence, or both.
In family law matters, subpoenas are often used to obtain financial records, medical documents, or other information relevant to parenting or property disputes.
If you receive a subpoena, you must comply with it unless you successfully object and the court agrees to set it aside or modify its scope.
Key Takeaway: A subpoena requires you to provide documents or evidence in family court. If you believe it is unfair or unreasonable, you may have grounds to object.
Grounds for Objecting to Subpoena Family Court
You can object to a subpoena on several grounds, including:
1. The Subpoena is Too Broad or Oppressive
If a subpoena requests an excessive amount of information or imposes an unreasonable burden, you may argue that it is oppressive. This could be the case if complying would require significant time, effort, or expense that is disproportionate to the needs of the case.
2. The Documents or Evidence are Irrelevant
A subpoena should only request documents or evidence that are directly relevant to the family law proceedings. If the requested material has no real connection to the issues being decided, you may argue that the subpoena should be set aside.
3. Legal Professional Privilege Applies
If a subpoena seeks documents that contain confidential legal advice between you and your lawyer, you can object on the basis of legal professional privilege. The court will generally uphold this objection unless the privilege has been waived.
4. The Information is Confidential or Private
Some types of information, such as medical records or counselling notes, may be protected by confidentiality laws. If disclosing the material would breach privacy laws or cause unnecessary harm, you may have grounds to object.
5. The Subpoena is an Abuse of Process
If a subpoena is being used for improper purposes—such as to harass, intimidate, or gain an unfair advantage—it may be considered an abuse of process. The court has the power to reject subpoenas that are being misused in this way.
Key Takeaway: You can object to a subpoena if it is overly broad, irrelevant, privileged, confidential, or being used unfairly. The court will consider whether the request is reasonable and necessary.
Need a Lawyer?
How to Object to a Subpoena in Family Court
If you want to object to a subpoena, you must follow the correct legal procedure.
1. File a Notice of Objection
In family law cases, you usually need to file a formal notice of objection with the court. This document outlines the reasons why you believe the subpoena should be set aside or limited.
2. Attend a Court Hearing (if Required)
The court may schedule a hearing to decide whether the subpoena should stand. You (or your lawyer) will need to present arguments explaining why the subpoena is unreasonable or unnecessary.
3. The Court’s Decision
The court will consider your objections and decide whether to:
- Set aside the subpoena entirely
- Modify its scope to make it more reasonable
- Require you to comply with some or all of the requests
Key Takeaway: To object to a subpoena, you must file an objection with the court and may need to attend a hearing. The court will decide whether to set it aside or modify its terms.
Also read: How Do You Get a DNA Test: 2 Methods You Need to Know
Should You Seek Legal Advice?
Objecting to a subpoena can be a complex process, and mistakes could result in having to comply with the subpoena despite your concerns.
A lawyer can help assess whether you have strong grounds for objection and guide you through the legal process.
Legal advice is particularly important if the subpoena involves confidential information, privileged documents, or potential legal risks.